Free trial: definition, card-upfront math and the rules that apply

A free trial gives paid features for a fixed time before the customer pays. The math for card-upfront versus no-card trials and the US auto-renewal rules.

Definition

A free trial gives full or near-full access to a paid product for a fixed period, such as 14 days, after which the user pays or loses access. Trials without a card get more starters; trials with a card upfront get fewer starters and convert more of them. Compare the two on paid customers per visitor.

  • Paid customers per visitor = trial start rate × trial-to-paid rate, the only fair way to compare trial types.
  • A card-upfront trial is a negative option offer in US law, with disclosure, consent and cancellation rules.

A free trial lets someone use the paid product for a fixed time before paying. Example: a project management app gives new teams 14 days of its Business plan, then asks for a card or locks the workspace.

How it works

Trials come in two forms. An opt-in trial asks for nothing upfront, and the user has to choose to pay at the end. An opt-out trial takes a card at signup and charges it unless the user cancels.

The metric that compares them is paid customers per visitor:

Text
paid customers per visitor = trial start rate × trial-to-paid rate

Example with 10,000 visitors:

Trial typeTrials startedTrial-to-paidPaid customers
No card8% = 80015%120
Card upfront2.5% = 25050%125

A 50% conversion rate looks like a rout next to 15%, yet the outcome is close to a tie. Which form wins depends on your product and your traffic, so measure it on paid customers or revenue per visitor.

Why it matters for pricing

Trials delay revenue, and that changes how you read a price test. With a 14-day trial, a price shown today produces its first payment two weeks later, so a test has to run past the trial length before it says anything. The price a visitor saw at signup must also be the price they pay at the end. Leverprice keeps each visitor on their first price with a signed first-party cookie, and signed-in users across devices through their user ID.

Card-upfront trials are negative option offers in US law. The Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act requires a clear disclosure of all material terms before you collect billing details, the customer's express informed consent before you charge, and a simple way to stop recurring charges (15 U.S.C. § 8403). California adds that an offer with a free trial must say how to cancel, and let the customer cancel, before they pay; a trial longer than 31 days needs a notice 3 to 21 days before it ends (Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 17602). This is not legal advice.

Common mistakes

  • A trial shorter than the time it takes to reach the product's first real result.
  • Comparing trial types on trial-to-paid rate alone.
  • Hiding the automatic charge, which breaks the disclosure rules above and invites disputes.
  • Showing one price at signup and charging another when the trial ends.

A reverse trial drops non-payers to a free plan instead of locking them out, and freemium removes the clock entirely. Trial results show up in your conversion rate, and sticky assignment keeps a tested price stable from signup to the first charge.

Frequently asked questions

Should a free trial require a credit card?

Test it. A card upfront cuts the number of trials and raises the share that pays, and the better option is the one with more paid customers, or more revenue, per visitor.

How long should a SaaS free trial be?

Long enough for a typical user to reach the result they signed up for. Check how many days your converting users needed to get there, and set the trial just past that.

Do I have to send a reminder before a trial ends?

California requires one for trials longer than 31 days, sent 3 to 21 days before the trial ends. Check the rules in each market you sell to; a reminder also cuts surprise charges and the disputes that follow them.