Definition
Grandfathering means existing customers keep their old price after you raise prices for new customers. It protects goodwill and limits churn during an increase, but it costs the price gap on every grandfathered account every month. Compare that cost with the break-even churn of raising everyone: (new price - old price) ÷ new price.
- Grandfathering 400 customers at $19 while new ones pay $29 costs $4,000 of MRR, or $48,000 a year.
- Raising those 400 customers to $29 loses revenue only if more than 34.5% of them cancel.
Grandfathering means letting existing customers keep the price they signed up at when you raise it for everyone new. Example: you move Pro from $19 to $29 a month for new signups, and your 400 current subscribers keep paying $19.
How it works
The cost is the gap times the accounts it covers:
monthly cost of grandfathering = grandfathered accounts × (new price - old price)
= 400 × ($29 - $19) = $4,000 of MRRThe alternative is to raise everyone and accept some cancellations. The break-even churn tells you how many you can lose:
break-even churn = (new price - old price) ÷ new price
= ($29 - $19) ÷ $29 = 34.5%If 10% of the 400 cancel, the rest pay 360 × $29 = $10,440 a month, against $7,600 if everyone stays at $19. The price increase calculator runs this for your own numbers.
Grandfathering comes in several forms: permanent, time-limited (for example, the old price for 12 more months), until the customer changes plans, or partial, where existing customers move halfway to the new price.
Why it matters for pricing
Grandfathering is the default in a price test. A test changes the price new visitors see at checkout, while existing subscriptions keep billing at the price stored in your payment provider. In Leverprice, renewals never count toward a test, so each price is judged on first payments minus refunds.
That makes the order of work simple: find the better price on new customers first, then decide separately what to do with existing ones. How to raise SaaS prices covers that second step, including how to announce it.
Common mistakes
- Grandfathering forever by default, which leaves you with a pile of legacy prices to support.
- Not telling grandfathered customers they are on an old price, so they never value it.
- Dropping the old price without warning when the customer changes plans.
- Raising existing customers with no notice at all.
Related terms
Churn rate is the number the break-even formula is compared against, and the gap shows up directly in MRR. Price elasticity predicts how many customers an increase will cost, and a lifetime deal is grandfathering taken to its limit.
Frequently asked questions
Should I grandfather existing customers when I raise prices?
Run the break-even math first. If the share of customers you would expect to lose is well below the break-even churn, raising everyone earns more; grandfathering buys goodwill at a known monthly cost.
How long should grandfathering last?
Long enough to feel fair, for example a fixed 6 or 12 months announced up front. A deadline turns an open-ended cost into a planned migration.
Does grandfathering apply to annual plans?
Usually until the renewal date at least, since the customer already paid for the year. The question is what price applies at renewal, so decide that before you announce the change.