Definition
Decoy pricing adds an option few people should choose, priced to make a neighboring option look better. The decoy is worse than its target on every point that matters and costs about the same. Studies since 1982 find the effect mostly when options are compared as numbers, as on a pricing page, and rarely when buyers experience the products directly.
- In the example below, a decoy lifts the average order from $31.00 to $35.30, so it pays only if conversion falls by less than 12.2%.
- Test a decoy on revenue per visitor; a bigger share for the target plan proves nothing on its own.
Decoy pricing means adding a plan you don't expect to sell so that the plan next to it looks like the obvious deal. Example: a WordPress maintenance tool offers Starter at $19 for 3 sites, Pro at $49 for 25 sites with daily backups, and Plus at $45 for 8 sites without backups. Plus exists to make Pro look cheap.
How it works
The decoy is asymmetrically dominated: the target beats it on every attribute, while the other option does not. Huber, Payne and Puto showed in 1982 that adding such an option can raise the share of the option that dominates it, which breaks the regularity rule that a new option should never increase an existing option's share (Journal of Consumer Research).
Illustration of the effect on revenue, as the share of buyers choosing each plan:
| Lineup | Starter $19 | Plus $45 | Pro $49 | Average order |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Without the decoy | 60% | not offered | 40% | $31.00 |
| With the decoy | 45% | 5% | 50% | $35.30 |
If conversion holds, revenue per visitor rises 13.9%. The decoy breaks even if conversion falls 12.2%, because $31.00 ÷ $35.30 = 0.878, and it loses money beyond that.
Why it matters for pricing
The research is less settled than the popular examples suggest. Frederick, Lee and Baskin (2014) found the effect mostly appears when products are described with stylized numbers, and typically not when people experience the product directly or see an attribute shown as a picture (Journal of Marketing Research).
A SaaS pricing table is about as numerical as choices get, so a decoy may work there. You only find out by testing it, and the metric is revenue per visitor, since a decoy can shift buyers toward Pro while the extra option makes fewer visitors buy anything.
Common mistakes
- A decoy that is a decent deal, so people buy it and you end up supporting a plan you never wanted.
- Judging the decoy by the target plan's share instead of revenue per visitor.
- Adding a decoy and changing prices in the same test, so you can't tell which change worked.
- A decoy so obvious that buyers read it as a trick and trust the rest of the page less.
Related terms
Price anchoring is the related effect of a reference number, and good-better-best pricing is the lineup a decoy usually sits in. Tiered pricing covers how the steps between plans are set.
Frequently asked questions
Is decoy pricing ethical?
It stays honest when the decoy is a real plan you will sell and support on the stated terms. A plan that cannot actually be bought is a false claim.
Where does the decoy go on the pricing page?
Next to its target, in the same layout and at a similar price, so the comparison takes a second and the gap is obvious.
How do you test a decoy?
Run the lineup with and without it over the same period and compare revenue per visitor. A rise in the target plan's share means nothing if total revenue doesn't move.