Good-better-best pricing: definition, the middle-plan math and how to test it

Good-better-best pricing offers three versions at rising prices. Why the middle plan gains share, and how to judge a lineup by revenue per visitor.

Definition

Good-better-best pricing offers three versions of a product at rising prices, each adding features or capacity. Buyers sort themselves by need, and the middle option tends to gain share because it looks like the safe compromise. The lineup's job is to raise average revenue per customer without losing buyers who only want the cheapest plan.

  • Lineup ARPU = the sum of each plan's share times its price; a 20/60/20 split over $8, $16 and $32 gives $17.60.
  • Judge a lineup change by revenue per visitor, not by how many buyers picked the middle plan.

Good-better-best pricing means selling three versions of the same product at three prices. Example: a screen recorder offers Basic at $8, Pro at $16 and Team at $32 a month. It is the same app at three levels of capacity, with a clear step between each.

How it works

Each buyer picks the cheapest version that covers their needs, so the lineup's revenue depends on the mix.

Text
ARPU = sum of (share choosing the plan × plan price)
     = 20% × $8 + 60% × $16 + 20% × $32
     = $1.60 + $9.60 + $6.40 = $17.60

Compare that with a single $12 plan. Illustration: if the single plan converts 3.0% of visitors and the three-plan lineup converts 2.8%, revenue per visitor is 3.0% × $12 = $0.36 against 2.8% × $17.60 = $0.49. The lineup can convert a little worse and still win.

The middle plan does extra work. In a 1989 study, Itamar Simonson found that an option gains share when it becomes the compromise between two others (Journal of Consumer Research). Put the plan you want most buyers on in the middle, and give the top plan a real reason to exist, because it also sets the reference the middle is judged against.

Why it matters for pricing

The three prices interact. Raising Pro from $16 to $20 pushes some buyers down to Basic and a few up to Team, so the effect of one price shows up in all three plans. Testing one plan's conversion in isolation misses most of that.

Judge a lineup change by revenue per visitor across all three plans, and keep the features fixed while you test prices, or you won't know which change did the work.

Common mistakes

  • A middle plan without a feature most buyers need, so it reads as filler.
  • Steps so small that buyers can't see the difference, or so large that Basic users never consider moving up.
  • Optimizing the share of the middle plan instead of total revenue.
  • Fences picked at random instead of along how customers grow, such as seats, projects or usage.

Tiered pricing covers the quantity version of steps, and decoy pricing adds an option built to lose. The top plan also works as a price anchor, and ARPU is the number the whole lineup exists to move.

Frequently asked questions

Why three plans instead of two or four?

Three gives buyers a low, a middle and a high option, which creates both the compromise effect and an anchor. Two plans lose the middle, and four or more make the choice harder to read.

Should the middle plan be highlighted?

If it is the plan most buyers should pick, yes, and a "most popular" label is a common cue. Make sure the label is true.

How far apart should the prices be?

Far enough that each step buys something obvious. The example above doubles at each step; start from the value each plan adds, then test.