Price anchoring: definition, the research and how to use it honestly

Price anchoring makes buyers judge a price against the first number they see. The research behind it, and the US rules on was-and-now price claims.

Definition

Price anchoring is the tendency to judge a price against the first number you saw. A $499 plan makes $99 look modest, and a crossed-out $49 makes $29 look like a deal. Anchors work even when they are arbitrary, which is why US guidance requires a former price to be one you genuinely offered for a reasonable period.

  • Perceived discount = (anchor - price) ÷ anchor, so a crossed-out $49 turns $29 into 40.8% off.
  • To test a price, keep every anchor on the page identical across variants; to test an anchor, keep the price fixed.

Price anchoring means the first price a buyer sees becomes the yardstick for every price after it. Example: a pricing page that shows an Enterprise plan at $499 a month before Business at $99 makes $99 read as the sensible choice, while the same $99 next to a $19 plan reads as expensive.

How it works

Anchors pull estimates toward them even when they are obviously random. In Tversky and Kahneman's 1974 experiment, people who first saw a wheel of fortune stop at 10 gave a median estimate of 25% for the share of African countries in the UN, and people who saw 65 gave 45% (Science).

Prices behave the same way. In a 2003 study by Ariely, Loewenstein and Prelec, MBA students first considered buying products at a price equal to the last two digits of their social security number, and those with above-median numbers then stated values 57% to 107% higher (Quarterly Journal of Economics).

In software, the anchors you control are the plans around a price, the monthly price shown next to an annual one, a competitor's price you cite and a former price. A crossed-out anchor sets the discount buyers perceive:

Text
perceived discount = (anchor - price) ÷ anchor
                   = ($49 - $29) ÷ $49 = 40.8%

Why it matters for pricing

Anchors change conversion at the same price, which matters twice for testing. To test a price, keep every anchor on the page identical across variants. To test an anchor, keep the price fixed and change only the anchor, then compare revenue per visitor.

Fake anchors carry legal risk in the US. The FTC's Guides Against Deceptive Pricing treat a former-price comparison as legitimate when the former price is the actual, bona fide price the item was offered at on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period, and as fictitious when an inflated price was set up to advertise a large reduction (16 CFR 233.1). This is not legal advice.

Common mistakes

  • A permanent "was $49" that was never the real price.
  • An anchor so far from your audience that it scares them off, such as a $5,000 plan on a page for solo developers.
  • Changing anchors and prices in the same test.
  • Showing an annual plan as a monthly figure without saying it is billed yearly.

Decoy pricing uses a whole plan as the anchor, and good-better-best pricing gives every lineup a built-in one. Charm pricing works on the digits instead of the reference, and willingness to pay is what anchors move.

Frequently asked questions

Showing higher plans or competitor prices is ordinary. In the US, a former-price comparison must use a price you genuinely offered for a reasonable period, under the FTC's pricing guides.

Does showing an annual plan as a monthly price count as anchoring?

Yes. The monthly plan's price becomes the anchor for the annual discount, so show the amount billed each year clearly to keep the comparison honest.

Do anchors work on experienced buyers?

The 2003 study used MBA students who had a real chance of having to buy at the price they stated, and the anchor still moved their valuations. Expect experienced buyers to be anchored too.